Abstract

The Variable Stripe Length (VSL) method is a very popular tool to measure the optical gain in thin film active devices. However, over the last decade experimental and theoretical evidence has been reported that cast doubt upon its reliability and that seriously discourages its application. Continuing in the path of highlighting the uncertainties associated with this method, this Letter soundly demonstrates that the particular choice of stripe lengths in the VSL measurements profoundly influences the optical gains retrieved by this method. Thus, a single set of VSL data may render gain values that differ by tens of cm^-1. The observed gain variability is ascribed to a combination of unavoidable experimental noise and incorrect assumptions in the analytical treatment (small-signal approximation).

© 2017 Optical Society of America

On the characteristic lengths in the variable stripe length method for optical gain measurements

L. Cerdán, A. Costela, and I. García-Moreno
J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 27(9) 1874-1877 (2010)

Radiative recombination rate measurement by the optically pumped variable stripe length method

Robert Thomas, Peter M. Smowton, and Peter Blood
Opt. Express 23(3) 3308-3315 (2015)

Cavity length matching and optical resonances in a Raman laser with the multimode pump source

Ruslan V. Chulkov, Vasyli Y. Markevich, Ahmed Y. Alyamani, Evgenii A. Cheshev, and Valentin A. Orlovich
Opt. Lett. 42(23) 4824-4827 (2017)

Efficient method for the measurement of lifetime optical damage performance of thin film coatings from laser damage size analysis

Selim Elhadj and Jae Hyuck Yoo
Opt. Lett. 42(16) 3153-3156 (2017)

Single-shot optical recorder with sub-picosecond resolution and scalable record length on a semiconductor wafer

R. Muir and J. Heebner
Opt. Lett. 42(21) 4414-4417 (2017)