We present a resonance waveguide grating with relatively wide bandwidth in the visible region of the spectrum compared to typical resonance structures. The reflective properties of the grating are based on amorphous atomic layer deposited titanium dioxide which has rather high refractive index at the visible wavelengths. The resonance grating provides approximately 20–30 nm bandwidth with over 90% reflectance at the visible wavelengths. The measured reflectances of the fabricated elements show also very good agreement with the theoretical predictions. These kind of reflectors may be useful in applications that make use of LED sources.
© 2011 Optical Society of America
Subwavelength gratings can exhibit resonance effects which can be utilized in many interesting applications such as filters, sensors, pulse-shapers, second-harmonic generation, and field enhancement of fluorescence [1–5]. Typically, these resonance waveguide gratings (RWG) are used as narrow band filters because the resonance effects produce very sharp peaks in the reflection spectrum. However, it has been recently shown theoretically that the RWG structures can also provide very wide bandwidths over which the reflectance is nearly 100% at the IR wavelengths [6–9]. To obtain a wide bandwidth, it is crucial to employ materials which have very high refractive index with negligible absorption. In the IR region there exists suitable materials, such as silicon and germanium, that fulfill these conditions. It has also been experimentally demonstrated by several authors that these materials can be used to fabricate broadband reflectors at the IR wavelengths [10–14].
At the visible wavelengths the lack of high-index materials prevents the realization of very wide bandwidths. Fortunately, there exists a few materials which have rather high refractive index at the visible wavelengths and therefore allow the design of RWG reflectors for which the bandwidth at the visible wavelengths is substantially wider than is achieved by typical resonance structures. In this paper we have designed and fabricated such structures using amorphous atomic layer deposited (ALD) titanium dioxide (TiO2) as a high-index material. These kind of reflectors may be useful, for example, in filtering or field enhancement applications which make use of LED sources.
2. Design of the RWG structure
Amorphous ALD TiO2 is a transparent material which has rather high refractive index and almost negligible absorption over the visible spectrum. The refractive index of amorphous ALD TiO2 is nearly 2.5 at the middle of the visible spectrum . Although this is among the highest refractive indices that can be used at the visible wavelengths, it is still far less than those of the materials that can be used at the IR wavelengths. For example, the refractive indices of silicon and germanium are greater than 3.4 and 4, respectively, at the wavelengths well above their bandgaps. Therefore, it is evident that broadband reflectors, for which the bandwidth is several hundreds of nanometers, cannot be realized at the visible wavelengths in the same manner as in the IR-region.
In this work we designed RWG reflectors employing the properties of ALD TiO2. Since we also wanted to fabricate the designed RWG structure, we chose a rather simple structure which is also suitable for mass production. The structure contains a binary linear SiO2 grating with uniform TiO2 layer deposited on the top of the grating. Therefore, it should be emphasized that it is also possible to obtain notably wider bandwidths at the visible wavelengths than our design provides by using certain multilayer structures or using additional low refractive index materials. However, these structures are problematic from the fabrication point of view and hence we chose to design and fabricate the easiest case.
We designed two similar RWG gratings for the incident angles of 20 and zero degrees where the former gives the reflection peak around the wavelength of 532 nm and the latter around the wavelength of 633 nm. Both structures are designed for TE-polarization, i.e., the polarization of the incident light is parallel to the grooves of the grating. The period of the first grating is d = 378 nm, the height of the grating hg = 106 nm, and the fill-factor f = 0.26. The thickness of the TiO2 coating is hc = 56 nm. The corresponding parameters of the second grating are d = 390 nm, hg = 120 nm, f = 0.25, and hc = 68 nm. The schematics of the grating structure is shown in Fig. 1.
3. Fabrication of the RWG and the optical properties of ALD TiO2
The RWG gratings were fabricated by patterning the SiO2 substrate by electron beam lithography and etched by using reactive ion etching. The TiO2 coating was atomic layer deposited on the SiO2 grating at 120°C temperature using Beneq TFS 500 reactor with TiCl4 and H2O precursor gases. The low temperature of 120°C leads to amorphous TiO2, which is smooth and has low losses . In ALD process, the film grows equally on all surfaces, which allows the realization of the design shown in Fig. 1. The cycle time in the ALD process was 2.8 s and the growth speed was 0.056 nm per cycle. Although this is quite a slow process, it scales very well and thus makes possible to coat large surface areas at the same time without significantly altering the cycle time.
The optical constants of the amorphous TiO2 were measured from a 110 nm thick TiO2 thin film on SiO2 substrate using variable angle ellipsometer (VASE) supplied by J.A. Woollam Co. The real part of the refractive index is shown in Fig. 2. The extinction coefficient is negligible at the wavelengths above the bandgap and therefore is not included in the figure.
The scanning electron microscope (SEM) image of the RWG structure operating at 20 degrees incident angle is shown in Fig. 3.
4. Measurements and results
The theoretical reflectance curves of the RWG reflectors were calculated by using Fourier modal method  and the optimization was carried out by using MATLAB’s Nelder-Mead Simplex method. The refractive index of amorphous TiO2 used in the simulations was obtained from the measured data presented in Fig. 2. The measurement of the experimental reflectance curves were carried out by using VASE ellipsometer. The reflectance of the RWG reflector with zero degrees incident angle was determined using transmission measurement because it is not possible to obtain the reflectance at zero degree incidence using VASE ellipsometer. At this point we note that reflectance throughout this paper refers to absolute reflectance.
In Fig. 4 is illustrated the experimental zeroth order reflectance curve and the corresponding theoretical reflectance curve for the RWG reflector with the incidence angle of 20 degrees using the designed parameters. The structure was optimized so that the center of the peak is at the wavelength of 532 nm. It can be seen that the experimental peak has shifted towards the shorter wavelengths. This shift may be caused by a slight deviation in the realized refractive index of TiO2 or in the thickness of the TiO2 layer. If either the thickness or the refractive index decreases, the peaks move to the shorter wavelengths.
The difference in the theoretical and experimental curves at the shorter wavelengths between 400 nm and 470 nm are caused by the rounding of the rectangular shapes in the fabricated element. The effect of rounding at the shorter wavelengths is treated more extensively shortly in the case of the second RWG reflector.
It should be noted that there exists non-zero diffraction orders in the substrate as well as in the reflection side because the incidence angle is not zero. The theoretical and experimental reflectances are the zeroth orders reflectances although the higher orders also contribute to the total reflectance at the wavelengths below the cut-off wavelength at 510 nm.
Figure 5 illustrates the corresponding experimental and theoretical curves of the RWG reflector at zero degrees incidence angle for which the center of the reflection peak was designed at the wavelength of 633 nm. Also in this case there is a slight deviation from the designed wavelengths in the experimental curves.
Since the substrate material is SiO2, it is evident that also non-zero diffraction orders will emerge in the substrate at the wavelengths below the cut-off wavelength at 574 nm. However, in the measurements the higher orders do not propagate after the SiO2 substrate but they instead undergo a total-internal reflection at the interface between the SiO2 substrate and air. Thus, it is not possible to measure the non-zero transmitted orders and therefore the experimental results at the wavelengths below the cut-off wavelength are not entirely correct in Fig. 5 if we assume that R = 1 − T. Since we were not able to measure the reflectance at zero degree incidence angle, we resolved this problem as follows: we calculated the theoretical transmittance where we take into account only the zeroth transmitted order (as in the measurements) and determined the reflectance using the relation R = 1 − T. We also used the rounded grating profile in order to obtain the best possible result to match the experimental results shown in Fig. 5. The above mentioned theoretical reflectance curves for the both polarizations are illustrated in Fig. 6 with the black and blue solid lines.
Now we can easily see in Fig. 6 that the curves with the solid line resemble quite well the experimental results shown in Fig. 5 which is of course as expected because in both cases we use only the zeroth order to determine the reflectance. Thus, we may conclude that the theoretical and experimental results are in rather good agreement with each other also at the shorter wavelengths although this cannot be seen in Fig. 5. Without the rounding of the grating profile the theoretical reflectance of the peak at the wavelength of 525 nm is approximately 50%.
Finally, we also calculated the theoretical reflectance using the rounded grating profile to see how the reflectance would behave if we had the means to measure it. These reflectance curves for the both polarizations are shown in Fig. 5 with the black and blue dashed lines.
In this work we have presented RWG reflectors with substantially wide bandwidth compared to typical RWG structures at the visible wavelengths. The reflector is based on amorphous ALD TiO2 which has very high refraction index at the visible region of the spectrum with negligible absorption. We also fabricated two example reflectors and showed that the theoretical and the experimental reflectance curves are in good agreement with each other. The example reflectors provided approximately 20–30 nm bandwidth with over 90% reflectance. These kind of RWG reflectors can be useful in filtering or field enhancement applications which take advantage of LED sources.
Finally, it should be noted that it is also possible to obtain flattop reflectance curves at the visible wavelengths using similar multilayer structures such as in Ref. . In these cases it is theoretically possible to obtain nearly 100% reflectance over more than a hundred nanometers bandwidth at the visible region of spectrum using ALD TiO2. However, from the fabrication point of view, these structures are rather difficult to realize because of the adjustment problems with different layers.
The work of T. Alasaarela and A. Lehmuskero was supported by the Finnish Graduate School of Modern Optics and Photonics. T. Alasaarela also acknowledges the Emil Aaltonen Foundation. I. Vartiainen acknowledges the Finnish Funding Agency for Technology and Innovation (TEKES).
References and links
1. R. Magnusson and S. S. Wang, “New principle for optical filters,” Appl. Phys. Lett. 61, 1022–1024 (1992). [CrossRef]
3. T. Vallius, P. Vahimaa, and J. Turunen, “Pulse deformations at guided-mode resonance filters,” Opt. Express 10, 840–843 (2002). [PubMed]
4. M. Siltanen, S. Leivo, P. Voima, M. Kauranen, P. Karvinen, P. Vahimaa, and M. Kuittinen, “Strong enhancement of second-harmonic generation in all-dielectric resonant waveguide grating,” Appl. Phys. Lett. 91, 111109 (2007). [CrossRef]
5. P. Karvinen, T. Nuutinen, O. Hyvärinen, and P. Vahimaa, “Enhancement of laser-induced fluorescence at 473 nm excitation with subwavelength resonant waveguide gratings,” Opt. Express 16, 16364–16370 (2008). [CrossRef] [PubMed]
6. C. F. R. Mateus, M. C. Y. Huang, Y. Deng, A. R. Neureuther, and C. J. Chang-Hasnain, “Ultrabroadband Mirror Using Low-Index Cladded Subwavelength Grating,” IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 16, 518–520 (2004). [CrossRef]
10. C. F. R. Mateus, M. C. Y. Huang, L. Chen, C. J. Chang-Hasnain, and Y. Suzuki, “Broad-band mirror (1.12–1.62 m) using a subwavelength grating,” IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 16, 1676–1678 (2004). [CrossRef]
11. L. Chen, M. C. Y. Huang, C. F. R. Mateus, C. J. Chang-Hasnain, and Y. Suzuki, “Fabrication and design of an integrable subwavelength ultrabroadband dielectric mirror,” Appl. Phys. Lett. , 88, 031102 (2006) [CrossRef]
12. J. M. Kontio, J. Simonen, K. Leinonen, M. Kuittinen, and T. Niemi, “Broadband infrared mirror using guided-mode resonance in a subwavelength germanium grating,” Opt. Lett. , 35, 2564–2566 (2010). [CrossRef] [PubMed]
13. H. Wu, J. Hou, W. Mo, D. Gao, and Z. Zhou, “A broadband reflector using a multilayered grating structure with multi-subpart profile,” Appl. Phys. B 99, 519–524 (2010). [CrossRef]
14. A. Ricciardi, S. Campopiano, A. Cusano, T. F. Krauss, and L. O’Faolain, “Broadband Mirrors in the Near-Infrared Based on Subwavelength Gratings in SOI,” IEEE Photon. J. 2, 696–702 (2010). [CrossRef]
15. T. Alasaarela, T. Saastamoinen, J. Hiltunen, A. Säynätjoki, A. Tervonen, P. Stenberg, M. Kuittinen, and S. Honkanen, “Atomic layer deposited titanium dioxide and its application in resonant waveguide grating,” Appl. Opt. 49, 4321–4325 (2010). [CrossRef] [PubMed]
16. J. Turunen, “Diffraction theory of microrelief gratings,” in Micro-optics: Elements, Systems and Applications, H. Herzig, ed. (Taylor & Francis, 1997).