We compare two recently developed multiple-frame deconvolution approaches for the reconstruction of structured illumination microscopy (SIM) data: the pattern-illuminated Fourier ptychography algorithm (piFP) and the joint Richardson–Lucy deconvolution (jRL). The quality of the images reconstructed by these methods is compared in terms of the achieved resolution improvement, noise enhancement, and inherent artifacts. Furthermore, we study the issue of object-dependent resolution improvement by considering the modulation transfer functions derived from different types of objects. The performance of the considered methods is tested in experiments and benchmarked with a commercial SIM microscope. We find that the piFP method resolves periodic and isolated structures equally well, whereas the jRL method provides significantly higher resolution for isolated objects compared to periodic ones. Images reconstructed by the piFP and jRL algorithms are comparable to the images reconstructed using the generalized Wiener filter applied in most commercial SIM microscopes. An advantage of the discussed algorithms is that they allow the reconstruction of SIM images acquired under different types of illumination, such as multi-spot or random illumination.
© 2016 Optical Society of AmericaFull Article | PDF Article
11 May 2016: A correction was made to the text on pages B14 and B19.
OSA Recommended Articles
Nadya Chakrova, Rainer Heintzmann, Bernd Rieger, and Sjoerd Stallinga
Opt. Express 23(24) 31367-31383 (2015)
Li-Hao Yeh, Lei Tian, and Laura Waller
Biomed. Opt. Express 8(2) 695-711 (2017)
Ruizhi Cao, Tingting Yang, Yue Fang, Cuifang Kuang, and Xu Liu
Appl. Opt. 56(24) 6930-6935 (2017)