Abstract

The Brekhovskikh variant of the Kirchhoff approximation (KA), as it applies to the description of the scattered field at large distances from a perfectly conducting sinusoidal grating (of amplitude h and period d) exposed to a plane wave of wavelength λ and incidence angle θ_i, is evaluated by means of energy-balance error calculations and comparisons with quasi-rigorous reference results obtained from the extensive form of the Rayleigh theory (RT). The RT is theoretically exact for all d/λ provided that h/d ≲ 0.072 and can be made to yield accurate numerical solutions at all θ_i and for all polarizations roughly for h/d < 0.39 − 0.0177 (d/λ) when d/λ ≤ 15. The KA is found to yield sufficiently accurate solutions at normal incidence only for roughly h/d < 0.011 (d/λ). Furthermore, the quality of the KA diminishes rapidly with increasing angle of incidence, as is shown by the fact that unacceptable errors occur for h/d ≳ 0.1 above θ_i ≃ 6°, for h/d ≳ 0.05 above θ_i ≃ 37°, and for h/d ≳ 0.016 above θ_i ≃ 63° at the period/wavelength ratio of 10. At higher frequencies (d/λ ≃ 36) there is some improvement in that, for example, the error becomes excessive for h/d ≳ 0.1 only above θ_i ≃ 25.5°. The KA proves to be unsafe at any frequency and incident angle as soon as h/d exceeds 0.13. This threshold is shown to be related to the onset of multiple scattering in the sense of geometrical optics.

© 1983 Optical Society of America

Improvement of the Kirchhoff approximation for scattering from rough surfaces

H. Faure-Geors and D. Maystre
J. Opt. Soc. Am. A 6(4) 532-542 (1989)

Explanation of λ⁻² optical scattering and λ⁻² Strehl on-axis irradiance reduction

M. Sparks
J. Opt. Soc. Am. 73(10) 1249-1254 (1983)

Validity of the Kirchhoff approximation for the scattering of electromagnetic waves from dielectric, doubly periodic surfaces

M. Franco, M. Barber, M. Maas, O. Bruno, F. Grings, and E. Calzetta
J. Opt. Soc. Am. A 34(12) 2266-2277 (2017)

Angular distribution of light scattered from a sinusoidal grating

Egon Marx, Thomas A. Germer, Theodore V. Vorburger, and Byong C. Park
Appl. Opt. 39(25) 4473-4485 (2000)

Numerical study of phase conjugation in stimulated Brillouin scattering from an optical waveguide

R. H. Lehmberg
J. Opt. Soc. Am. 73(5) 558-566 (1983)